Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in Cape May County, NJ & compare the best quotes from them.

Get Quotes From The Best & Compare

Top Home Insurance Companies in Cape May County, NJ

Home Insurance Company A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating Homeowners Insurance Market share
State Farm A 10.67%
Allstate A+ 9.18%
Erie A+ 8%
Travelers A++ 5.07%
Nationwide A+ 4.2%

Top Travelers Home Insurance Agents in Cape May County, NJ

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Donald B Elliott Insurance Agency Inc 19413 Jingle Shell Way Unit 1
19958
(302) 248-8500
Joshua Wayne Shockley 3692 LAKE AVE
8094
856-513-0609
Merrill Lynch Employees 1252 Forrest Ave
19904
(302) 678-2223
Hart Insurance Agency 710 Delsea Dr N
www.hartins.com 8028
(856) 589-2550
Email:service1@hartins.com
The Plastridge Agency Inc 45 N Main St
8062
Pyorre Insurance Agency Llc 1330 N Black Horse Pike Ste B
www.pyorre.com 8094
(856) 318-7181
Email:fortbragg@pyorre.com
George Royle Wright 3156 Route 9 S Ste 6
8242
(609) 770-8564
Stephenson And Meyer Insurance Agency Inc 315 Route 50
8330
(609) 829-3083
Email:john@smia4u.com
Combs Ins Services Agcy Inc 29848 Millsboro Hwy
www.thecombsagency.com 19966-3604
302-934-9393
Moore & Moore Insurance Agency 39 S MAIN ST 2ND FL
8062
(856) 678-6020
Email:mooreinsurance@hotmail.com

Top Erie Home Insurance Agents in Cape May County, NJ

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Grimsley Agency Of New York Llc 135 Michigan Ave
8201
(609) 272-0220
Advocate Insurance Group Llc 19716 Sea Air Ave Ste 1
19971-3800
302-227-3891
Tanner Insurance Agency Inc P O Box 569
www.tiains.com 19963
Insurance Services By Karen 216 E BROADWAY
8079
856-935-0845
Starr Insurance Agency 24 George St Somers\u00a0Point
8244
Alliance Insurance Of East Tn Inc. 1789 S Burlington Rd
08302-4303
856-451-6340
Casto Insurance Agency 2150 S Dupont Hwy
19934-1249
302-697-2650
Putnam White Lewis Insurance Agency Inc. 106 S White Horse Pike
8009
(856) 767-3399
The Insurance Buffet Llc 10 E Main St Suite E
www.theinsurancebuffet.com 8832
(856) 776-7399
Email:kkinsurancebuffet@gmail.com

Top State Farm Home Insurance Agents in Cape May County, NJ

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Ron Moreland 319 E Jimmie Leeds Rd Ste 300
www.ronmoreland.com 8205
(609) 241-1503
Wade Billingsley 101 N Washington Ave Ste 7 Margate
www.wadebillingsley.com 8402
Lamar Hodge 9 North Washington Avenue Margate
8402
Anthony Gargano 315 Delsea Dr N
www.tonygarg.com 08028-1403
856-881-6330
Jim Tanner 1154 GOVERNORS AVE S
19904
302-674-3500
Jim Thibodea 736 N DUPONT HWY
19901
302-883-5000
Aaron Achenbach 28354 Lews Georgtwn Hwy
www.831auto.com 19968-3115
302-664-1640
Martin Deutsch 22836 Dupont Hwy
www.martinsf.com 19947
(302) 856-6601
Al Adams 3471 S Delsea Dr
www.aladamsinsurance.com 08360-7449
856-825-7100
Kent Wilson 1409 CANTILLON BLVD
8330
609-399-0060

Top Nationwide Home Insurance Agents in Cape May County, NJ

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
David L May Jr 3003 English Creek Ave
8234
(609) 645-6999
Shawn Ruddy 1601 New Road Ste 100 Po Box 225
8225
(609) 385-0345
David Noma Agency 1420 S Lincoln Ave
8361
(856) 692-1514
Nancy L. Kowalski 500 E ABSECON BLVD
8201
609-641-3000
Spotts Insurance Group Inc 20 East Division Street
19903
Thomas L Crumrine 453 White Horse Pike
8201
Charles Pacholkiw 3728 N Dupont Hwy
19901-1555
302-678-0499
William Norman Snyder 3069 English Creek Avenue Twp.
8234
Arleen B Miller Lutcf 2303 New Rd
08225-1406
609-646-0600
David T Chudyk Agency Llc 5851 Route 42
8012
(609) 654-7342

Top Allstate Home Insurance Agents in Cape May County, NJ

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Heartland Financial 135 Michigan Ave
8201
(609) 272-0220
Eduardo Villarreal 2326 New Rd
8225
(609) 646-9357
Merrill-Hancock & Turner Insurance Inc. 1221 College Park Dr STE 116
19904-8724
(302) 678-9901
West Valley Ins. 4 Village Square
19977
(302) 223-3512
Kent Taylor 2021 RTE 9 UNITE 5
8221
609-904-5457
Nancy M. Gervasi 1450 E CHESTNUT AVE BLDG 5
8361
(856) 692-4500
Joshua Short 333 DUTCH MILL RD
8328
856-694-2222
Winston Brodmerkel 1099 Highway 77
8302
Joshua Weeks 679 LANDIS AVE
8352
856-451-9531
Andres Insurance Agency 1 S Independence Blvd
19904-3381
302-734-8268

Homeowners Insurance Comparison for the Cheapest Premiums in Cape May County, NJ

NationwideTravelersAllstate
Median Home Value ($) 265,950295,950265,950
Construction year 201120031947
Home Coverage ($) $400000-$500000$500000-$600000$500000-$600000
Total Premium ($) $1509$1998$2194

Cape May County, NJ Multi Policy Discounts by Home Insurance Companies

Home Insurance Company Multi Policy Discount (%)
Travelers upto 6%
Erie upto 23%
Nationwide upto 11%
Allstate upto 24%